logo English
  • English Français Español العرببية 中文 Русский فارسی
Contact Us
  • Follow us:
  •  
    • News
      • Latest news Special issues Newsletter
    • Get involved
      • Global campaigns Tools Become a member Networks Activists Alerts Jobs Contact Us
    • Facts and figures
      • Worldwide database Library
    • About Us
      • Presentation History How we work Member organizations Legal information
    • Member access
  •  
  •  
  • Homepage 12th World Day Against the Death Penalty: Mental Health Indian ruling highlights importance of next World Day
  •  
    • Indian ruling highlights importance of next World Day Mental illness

      Indian ruling highlights importance of next World Day

      Article by Emile Carreau published on February 03rd, 2014

      On 21 January, India’s Supreme Court formally banned the execution of mentally ill prisoners and in doing so highlighted why this year’s World Day against the Death Penalty, which is dedicated to issues of mental health, is so important.

      twitter facebook

    • The Court (pictured) ruled in favour of two prisoners who petitioned for a commutation of their death sentences to life imprisonment, claiming “the unconscionably long delay in deciding the mercy petition has caused the onset of chronic psychotic illness”.
      It acknowledged the “unbearable mental agony after confirmation of death sentence” and added that in some cases “death-row prisoners lost their mental balance on account of prolonged anxiety and suffering experienced on death row”.

      “The march of civilisation”

      Worldcoalition.org spoke to lead counsel for the petitioners, Yug Chaudhry, who affirmed that the physical conditions on death row in India exacerbate the prisoners’ emotional distress (also know as death row phenomenon).
      According to the Death Penalty Worldwide database, the conditions on death row in India are “harsh and life-threatening”. Prisoners on death row in Tihar Jail, Delhi, are “kept in solitary confinement in high-security cells no larger than 10 sq. feet.” High rates of suicide are also reported in Indian prisons.
      “The judgement is a tribute to the independence of the judiciary, constitutional values and the evolving standards of decency which characterises the march of civilization,” said Chaudhry
      He added: “Very few nations still execute prisoners who are mentally ill. India has not executed a mentally ill prisoner for more than 30 years. But the formal ban on doing so was handed down for the first time in this verdict. I think it will influence other countries, especially because among the retentionist countries, India is the most populous, among the biggest geographically, and looms large in Asia.”
      Japan is one of the countries with the most serious cases of mental illness on death row, and it will be one at the heart of this year’s World Day Against the Death Penalty.
      On 10 October, 2014, abolitionists around the world will highlight the links between capital punishment and mental disorders – and progress made in those countries that have made efforts to break them.

      “Well-established canons of human rights”

      In coming to its position, the Indian Supreme Court referred to the “well-established canons of human rights”, which prohibit the execution of the mentally ill.
      “The directions of the United Nations International Conventions, of which India is a party, clearly show that insanity/mental illness/schizophrenia is a crucial supervening circumstance, which should be considered by this Court in deciding whether in the facts and circumstances of the case death sentence could be commuted to life imprisonment,” it remarked.
      The ruling mentioned Resolution 2000/65 of the United Nations’ Human Rights Commission, which urges “all States that still maintain the death penalty... not to impose the death penalty on a person suffering from any form of mental disorder or to execute any such person”.
      At the end of the judgement the Court listed guidelines to safeguard the interest of the death row convicts. Number 8 requires there to be “regular mental health evaluation(s) of all death row convicts and appropriate medical care should be given to those in need”.

    • Related

      • 11th World Day against the Death Penalty: Greater Caribbean World Day 11th World Day against the Death Penalty: Greater Caribbean Campaign published on May 31st, 2013

    • Same issue

      • World Day Against the Death Penalty interview on France 24 Video World Day Against the Death Penalty interview on France 24 Video published on October 10th, 2014
      • UN Secretary Ban Ki-moon: Video UN Secretary Ban Ki-moon: "The death penalty has no place in the 21st century" Video published on October 10th, 2014
      • Mental health and the death penalty Video Mental health and the death penalty Video published on October 10th, 2014
      • Death penalty fails to spare people with intellectual disability: expert Video Death penalty fails to spare people with intellectual disability: expert Video published on September 25th, 2014
      • Solitary confinement on death row is mental torture: psychiatrist Video Solitary confinement on death row is mental torture: psychiatrist Video published on September 25th, 2014
      • Dialogue should make death penalty “a sentence of the past” – foreign ministers World Day Dialogue should make death penalty “a sentence of the past” – foreign ministers Article by World Coalition Against the Death Penalty published on October 09th, 2014
      • AGM focuses on mental health and progress in the Caribbean World Coalition AGM focuses on mental health and progress in the Caribbean Article by Inès Oulmokhtar published on May 16th, 2014
      • World Coalition raises mental health issues in administration of the death penalty AGM World Coalition raises mental health issues in administration of the death penalty Article by Thomas Hubert (in San Juan, Puerto Rico) published on June 22nd, 2014
      • Calendar of events for World Day 2014 World Day Calendar of events for World Day 2014 Article by World Coalition Against the Death Penalty published on August 19th, 2014
      • ECPM takes social media campaign to the fair ground World Day ECPM takes social media campaign to the fair ground Article by Bronwyn Dudley published on September 16th, 2014
      • Death penalty systems disregard mental health – experts World Day Death penalty systems disregard mental health – experts Article by Thomas Hubert published on September 25th, 2014
      • Links between death penalty and mental health exposed from Japan to Nigeria World Day Links between death penalty and mental health exposed from Japan to Nigeria Article by Thomas Hubert published on October 15th, 2014
      • French youth event emboldens next abolitionist generation World Day French youth event emboldens next abolitionist generation Article by Bronwyn Dudley published on October 22nd, 2014
    • Keywords
    • Mental Illness International law Death Row Conditions Death Row Phenomenon
    • Attached documents
    • Supreme Court of India ruling in Shatrughan Chauhan & Anr. Versus Union of India & Ors. | English |
    • The Advocacy Handbook: A Guide to Implementing Recommendations of the Criminal Justice/Mental Health Consensus Project | English |
    • Death Penalty and Mental Illness | English |
    • Other Articles
    • Kazakhstan Ratifies the Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPRGood news Kazakhstan Ratifies the Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR
    • DPIC’s Report on the 2020 Death Penalty Usage in the US USA DPIC’s Report on the 2020 Death Penalty Usage in the US
    • Statement on the Adoption of the 8th UN General Assembly Resolution for a Moratorium on the Use of the Death PenaltyStatement Statement on the Adoption of the 8th UN General Assembly Resolution for a Moratorium on the Use of the Death Penalty
  • logo footer
  • Legal information
    Contrat Creative Commons
  • World Coalition Against The Death Penalty
    Contact Us
  • 69 rue Michelet
    93100 Montreuil
    France