The Supreme Court of Kenya declares the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional

Homepage The campaign for the abolition of the death penalty on the African continent The Supreme Court of Kenya declares the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional

- Good news
  The Supreme Court of Kenya declares the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional
  Article by Thalia Gerzso published on January 23rd, 2018
  On December 14, 2017, the Supreme Court of Kenya declared the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional. This landmark decision puts an end to several years of uncertainties and constitutes an additional step towards the abolition of the death penalty in the country.
- With the assistance of Death Penalty Project, the International Commission of Jurists, and the Kenyan National Commission on Human Rights, Wilson Mwangi and Francis Karioko filed a petition to the Supreme Court questioning the constitutionality of the mandatory death penalty for the crimes such as murder, treason and armed robbery. In their petition, both defendants argued that mandatory death penalty violated their right to a fair trial and constituted an arbitrarily deprivation of life. In his ruling, the Supreme Court’s judge Njoki Ndungu held that mandatory death penalty is “inconsistent” with the Constitution of Kenya: “The mandatory nature of the death sentences as provided under Section 204 of the Penal Code, is hereby, declared unconstitutional.”
  
  More discretionary power for the Kenyan judges
  A mandatory sentencing scheme is one where the imposition of a death sentence is automatic upon conviction of a crime. Indeed, Section 204 of the Penal Code stated that “anyone found guilty of committing murder, treason and armed robbery shall be sentenced to death.” Thus, this provision did not allow judges to have discretion or to consider mitigating circumstances. For instance, a court would not be permitted to consider mental disabilities or a clean criminal record: if found guilty, the defendant would be automatically sentenced to death. Putting an end to this system, the Supreme Court also asked the Attorney General and the Director of Public Prosecutions to review Mwangi and Karioko’s case but also all murder and robbery with violence cases similar as pertains sentencing.
  
  The Supreme Court’s ruling marks the end of a period of uncertainty
  It is not the first time that a Kenyan court rules on the legality of the mandatory death penalty. In 2010, the Court of Appeal at Mombasa held that the mandatory death penalty violated the right to life and the right to protection against arbitrariness and inhuman treatment. Despite this ruling, the Penal Code retained mandatory death sentences. In 2013, the Court of Appeal at Nairobi did not uphold the Mombasa precedent. Considering that it was up to the legislature to decide whether to retain the mandatory death penalty, the Court of Appeal of Nairobi applied the mandatory death penalty for armed robbery. Hence, the Supreme Court recent decision ended the conflict and definitively ruled on the unconstitutionality of the mandatory death penalty.
  
  The decline of the mandatory death penalty
  The Supreme Court of Kenya’s ruling illustrates a regional and global trend. According to the Cornell Center on the Death Penalty Worldwide, at least 18 countries have discarded the mandatory death penalty since 2000. Because the mandatory death penalty violates the right to a fair trial and access to justice, the Supreme Court of Malawi struck down the mandatory death penalty as unconstitutional in 2007. Two years later, the Supreme Court of Uganda followed the lead. It did not adopt the same rationale, however. Indeed, Ugandan judges declared the mandatory death penalty unconstitutional because of it violates equal protection rights and discriminates between death eligible and non-death eligible defendants. Observers hope that this jurisprudential impulse will push countries like Botswana or Burkina Faso, to abolish the mandatory death penalty, still allowed under some circumstances.
  
  A first step towards a complete abolition of the death penalty in Kenya?
  The abolition of the mandatory death penalty can also be seen as another evidence of the Kenyan unwillingness to support the death penalty. Indeed, with no executions since 1987, Kenya is considered as a de facto abolitionist country. Kenya also issued large mass commutations. To alleviate “the mental anguish and suffering, psychological trauma and anxiety” due to extended stay on death row, President Mwai Kibaki commuted the sentences of 4,000 death row prisoners to life imprisonment in 2009. In 2016, President Uhuru Kenyatta commuted all death sentences to life jail terms, removing 2.747 prisoners from death row. Despite these encouraging signs, Kenya has not signed the Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR aiming at the abolition of the death penalty and Kenyan judges keep issuing death sentences. That is why abolitionists’ work remains more important than ever.
- Same issue
  - Africa Parliamentarians from French-speaking Africa commit to the abolition of the death penalty Article by Jessica Corredor published on January 17th, 2017
  - Protocol São Tomé and Príncipe ratifies OP2 and approves total and definitive abolition of the death penalty Article by Elise Guillot published on January 18th, 2017
  - Africa Towards the abolition of the death penalty in DRC: advances to be confirmed Article by Olivier LUNGWE FATAKI - Pax Christi Uvira published on December 13th, 2016
  - African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights Renewed calls for the abolition of the death penalty at the NGO forum and the 59th Session of the ACHPR Article by Jessica Corredor published on November 25th, 2016
  - World Day Africa raises its voice against the death penalty Article by Tiziana Trotta published on October 21st, 2016
  - African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights 58th Extraordinary Session of the ACHPR: a strong commitment of African states to a treaty providing the abolition of the death penalty Article by Guillaume Colin published on April 14th, 2016
  - Africa African Commission adopts draft Protocol on abolition Article by Maria Donatelli published on April 24th, 2015
  - Africa In Cameroon, the abolitionist network grows Article by Nestor Toko and Jessica Corredor published on October 28th, 2016
  - Africa Abolition of the death penalty in Guinea Article by Marion Gauer published on July 05th, 2016
  - Africa The abolitionists’ forum in Niger: a great success Article by Garba Illou Almoctar and Elise Guillot published on November 22nd, 2016
  - Africa Pardon Prisoners On Death Row Article by Lucy Peace Nantume published on November 08th, 2016
  - Protocol ACAT-CI commits to the ratification of OP2 in Côte d’Ivoire Article by N'guettia Yves Arsene Kouadio - ACAT Côte d'Ivoire published on January 04th, 2017
  - Good News Tanzania: President Magufuli declares his position against the death penalty. Article by Thalia Gerzso published on September 20th, 2017
  - Good News Gambia and Madagascar commit to irreversible abolition Article by Aurelie Placais published on September 22nd, 2017
  - Democratic Republic of the Congo: the abolitionists organize workshops for journalists Article by Thalia Gerzso published on September 25th, 2017
  - Africa Makwanyane Institute Is Launched at Cornell Law School Article by Sherrie Negrea, Cornell Law School published on July 17th, 2017
  - Africa Toward the abolition in Cameroon Article by Lorène du Crest et Nicolas Perron published on July 06th, 2017
  - African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights A major abolitionist gathering for the 60th ordinary session of the African Commission on Human and People’s Rights in Niger Article by Jessica Corredor published on May 19th, 2017
  - Report 12 Years Without an Execution: Is Zimbabwe Ready for Abolition? Article by Death Penalty Project published on May 24th, 2018
  - ACHPR The death penalty at the heart of the debates of the 62nd Ordinary Session of the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights Article by Guillaume Colin - Jessica Corredor published on May 15th, 2018
  - Joint Statement Mandatory Death Penalty for Blasphemy in Mauritania Article by World Coalition Against the death penalty published on May 11th, 2018
  - Report “Unknown Assailants: A Threat to Human Rights” Article by Legal Human Rights Centre published on May 04th, 2018
  - Regional Congress “It’s in Africa that we find the strongest dynamics towards abolition” Article by Clémentine Etienne published on April 24th, 2018
  - Statement World Coalition welcomes the success of the Regional Congress in Africa Article by World Coalition Against the Death Penalty published on April 12th, 2018
  - ACHPR « A new Gambia » welcomes the 61st session of the ACHPR Article by FIACAT and World Coalition against the Death Penalty published on November 21st, 2017
  - World Day Strong mobilization in Sub-Saharan Africa on World Day Article by Thalia Gerzso published on October 19th, 2017
  - Africa Innocent and Sentenced to Die: Wrongful Incarceration on Nigeria's Death Row Video published on October 14th, 2016
- Other Articles
- Philippines Call for actions on World Day in the Philippines
- Caribbean Call for actions on World Day in Barbados and the Eastern Caribbean States
- Statement COVID-19: Calling for a Worldwide Moratorium on the Death Penalty During the Pandemic